Rental Car Coverage After a Castle Rock Car Accident: Who Pays and for How Long
Your car is at the body shop. Or worse, it is in a salvage yard. You still have to get to work. You still have to get the kids to school. You still have to live your life.
So who pays for your rental car? How long does the coverage last? What happens when the insurance company tries to cut you off while your vehicle is still being repaired?
The rules are not as simple as “the at-fault driver’s insurance pays for everything.” They involve Colorado’s modified comparative fault law, your own policy’s rental reimbursement coverage, a Colorado Supreme Court case most drivers have never heard of, and your duty to mitigate damages. Here is how it actually works.
for a free consultation.
We advance all costs; you owe nothing unless we recover compensation for your family
Who Pays for Your Rental Car After a Colorado Crash?
Three potential sources. In order of preference:
Source 1: The at-fault driver’s liability insurance. If the other driver caused the crash and their liability is clear, their insurance should pay for a rental car during the time your vehicle is being repaired or until a total loss settlement is reached. This is called loss of use coverage under the at-fault driver’s property damage liability policy.
Source 2: Your own rental reimbursement coverage. If you purchased rental reimbursement as an endorsement on your own auto policy, your insurer pays up to the policy limits. Typical coverage structures include $30 per day up to $900 total, $50 per day up to $1,500 total, or similar combinations, depending on the carrier and policy. Source: Progressive – Rental Car Reimbursement Coverage; State Farm – Rental Reimbursement Coverage Explained; Travelers – Rental Reimbursement Coverage. This is first-party coverage you buy separately. It is not included in standard Colorado auto policies by default.
Source 3: Your own collision coverage plus subrogation. Some auto policies provide rental reimbursement automatically when a collision claim is opened. Your insurer pays up front, then recovers from the at-fault driver’s insurer through subrogation, including your deductible.
The best practice in a clear-liability crash: file directly with the at-fault driver’s insurer for property damage and loss of use, and use your own rental reimbursement coverage only as backup while the third-party claim is being processed.
How Long Does Rental Coverage Last?
Until your vehicle is repaired, or until the at-fault driver’s insurer makes a reasonable settlement offer on a total loss. That second phrase matters.
For repairable vehicles: Coverage lasts through the reasonable repair period. If the body shop takes three weeks because it is waiting for parts, the insurer generally must cover those three weeks. If the shop is slow for reasons unrelated to parts availability or proper repair procedures, the insurer may limit coverage to the “reasonable” repair duration for that type of damage.
For total loss vehicles: Coverage should last until the insurer makes a reasonable settlement offer, not until you accept it. Negotiating the offer is not grounds for the insurer to cut off rental coverage. That being said, once they make a reasonable offer, they can cancel the rental car so it is not always clear-cut when a rental car has to be returned or cut off as “reasonable” is somewhat subjective.
Practical tip: Request written confirmation from the at-fault driver’s insurer each week on the continued rental coverage. If they try to cut you off while your car is still in the shop, their written acknowledgment of the ongoing coverage becomes useful evidence if the dispute goes further.
What If Liability Is Disputed?
If the at-fault driver’s insurer is still investigating or denies liability, they will not pay for your rental up front. That is the ugliest part of property damage claims.
Your options in a disputed-liability situation:
Use your own collision and rental coverage. If you have both, your insurer will pay per your policy terms and then pursue subrogation against the at-fault driver’s insurer for reimbursement, including your deductible.
Pay out of pocket and seek reimbursement later. If you have no first-party coverage, you may need to front the rental costs while the liability dispute resolves. Keep every receipt. The at-fault driver’s insurer, if eventually found liable, must reimburse reasonable rental costs.
Pursue loss of use without a rental. Colorado law permits recovery of loss of use damages even if you never rent a replacement vehicle, as long as the costs are reasonable and properly documented. The measure is typically the fair rental value of a comparable vehicle for the reasonable period your vehicle was unavailable.
The PurCo v. Koenig Ruling: Why Loss of Use Matters
In 2012, the Colorado Supreme Court decided PurCo Fleet Services v. Koenig, 2012 CO 56, 285 P.3d 979, holding that a rental car company can recover loss of use damages from a negligent renter regardless of whether the company actually lost profits. Source: Auto Rental News – Explaining Loss-of-Use Damages to an Insurance Company.
Why this matters for everyday drivers: the case confirms that loss of use is a recoverable category of damages in Colorado, measured by the reasonable rental value of a comparable vehicle during the period the damaged vehicle is unavailable. You do not have to prove you actually lost money during the unavailable period; you only have to prove you lost the use of the vehicle during that period.
This is useful in cases where you did not rent a replacement (because you had another vehicle available, or because you managed without transportation) but still want to recover for the deprivation of use. The rental cost you could have reasonably incurred is your measure of damages.
Your Duty to Mitigate: What Happens If You Do Not Get Your Car Fixed Quickly?
Colorado law imposes a duty to mitigate damages on the party seeking recovery. That means you cannot let the rental clock run while the vehicle sits at the body shop waiting for you to make decisions. If you delay authorizing repairs, delay picking up a totaled vehicle, or let the rental continue while you shop for a replacement at your leisure, the insurer may limit your recovery to the period a reasonable person would have needed.
Practical rules of mitigation for rental car claims:
- Authorize repairs promptly once the estimate is approved
- If the vehicle is a total loss, begin shopping for a replacement immediately after you receive the settlement offer
- Return the rental when the replacement is available
- Do not upgrade the rental class beyond what is reasonable for your needs (a family SUV is reasonable if your totaled car was an SUV; a luxury rental is not)
The duty to mitigate cuts both ways. The insurer cannot force you to accept a substandard repair or an inadequate total loss offer just to end the rental clock. But you cannot drag the process out either.
The insurance company will pressure you to accept a rental cutoff before your car is fixed. We push back on your behalf.
Free consultation. Contingency-fee representation: no attorney fee unless we recover for you. Costs of litigation are advanced by the firm and reimbursed from the recovery.
Rental Class: What Kind of Rental Can You Get?
The general rule: you are entitled to a rental comparable in size and purpose to the vehicle you lost, not a luxury upgrade.
- If your totaled car was a midsize sedan, a midsize sedan rental is appropriate
- If your totaled vehicle was a minivan used for family transportation, a minivan or comparable SUV is appropriate
- If your totaled vehicle was a work truck used for contracting, a work truck or cargo van is appropriate
Some insurers will try to default you to the cheapest rental class regardless of your actual needs. Push back. You are entitled to a reasonable equivalent.
What If You Are in a Fault-Disputed Crash and Your Rental Runs Out?
This is the squeeze play insurers use: they refuse to pay for the rental until liability is resolved, and you run out of either money or rental coverage before the dispute is settled. If you are in this position:
- Document everything in writing. Send a letter or email to the at-fault driver’s insurer stating that you have incurred rental costs because of their delay and demanding reimbursement.
- Check whether your own collision and rental reimbursement coverage can bridge the gap.
- Contact an attorney. A brief attorney letter often moves a stalled claim faster than weeks of calls from a claimant.
- If the delay is unreasonable, the conduct may violate Colorado’s unfair claims settlement practices standards under C.R.S. § 10-3-1104. A complaint to the Colorado Division of Insurance can sometimes accelerate resolution.
Frequently Asked Questions: Rental Car Coverage After a Colorado Accident
Who pays for my rental car after a Colorado car accident?
If the other driver is at fault and their liability is clear, their auto liability insurance should pay for your rental car during the reasonable repair period or until a total loss settlement is offered. If you have rental reimbursement coverage on your own policy, that is a secondary source. If liability is disputed, you may need to pay out of pocket or use your own coverage and seek reimbursement later.
How long can I keep a rental car after an accident in Colorado?
For repairable vehicles: through the reasonable repair period. For total loss vehicles: until the at-fault driver’s insurer makes a reasonable settlement offer. After the offer is made, you have a reasonable period to select a replacement vehicle. The insurer is not required to continue rental coverage indefinitely while you negotiate.
What if I do not rent a car but I lose the use of my vehicle?
Colorado law permits recovery of loss of use damages even when no rental is incurred, consistent with the PurCo v. Koenig rule. The measure is typically the fair rental value of a comparable vehicle for the reasonable period your vehicle was unavailable.
Can the insurance company cut off my rental before my car is repaired?
Only if the repair period has become unreasonable (indicating failure to mitigate on your end) or if you have received a reasonable total loss offer. If the body shop is reasonably working on your vehicle and the insurer cuts off rental coverage, that is often grounds for a written demand and, if needed, a complaint to the Colorado Division of Insurance.
Do I need rental reimbursement on my own insurance policy?
It is optional but often valuable. Rental reimbursement protects you in hit-and-run situations, single-vehicle accidents, and any crash where liability will be disputed. Without it, you may have to front rental costs for weeks while the liability investigation plays out.
Will my own insurance rates go up if I use rental reimbursement on my policy?
Using your own coverage for a not-at-fault accident typically does not increase your rates, but policies vary. Check your policy terms. If you use your own collision coverage and your insurer successfully subrogates against the at-fault driver’s insurer, the claim often gets reclassified as not-at-fault.
How long do I have to file a claim arising from this accident?
Motor vehicle accident claims in Colorado carry a three-year statute of limitations under C.R.S. § 13-80-101(1)(n)(I), covering both bodily injury and property damage claims arising from the same crash.
Related Property Damage Resources
Related Practice Areas
Sources and Citations
- PurCo Fleet Services v. Koenig, 2012 CO 56, 285 P.3d 979
- UM Property Damage Coverage, C.R.S. § 10-4-610
- Unfair Claims Settlement Practices, C.R.S. § 10-3-1104
- Motor Vehicle Statute of Limitations, C.R.S. § 13-80-101(1)(n)(I)
- Auto Rental News, Explaining Loss-of-Use Damages to an Insurance Company, autorentalnews.com
- Progressive, Rental Car Reimbursement Coverage, progressive.com
- State Farm, Rental Reimbursement Coverage Explained, statefarm.com
- Travelers, Rental Reimbursement Coverage, travelers.com
- Colorado Division of Insurance, doi.colorado.gov
